CatSG

Cat News 66


Editorial

Asiatic cheetah

Twenty years ago, Peter Jackson wrote in the Editorial to Cat News 28 (1998): “The plight of the Asiatic cheetah has long been a matter of grave concern for the Cat Specialist Group”. This concern has not diminished. On the contrary, it is more justified than ever. The Asiatic cheetah could well be the next cat to go extinct.

Not more than 50 Asiatic cheetahs remain in the central Iranian plateau. The population has further decreased since 2008, when the population estimation was vaguely 70–110 animals. In some of the cheetah conservation areas, no cubs have been observed in recent years, in others not even females. Reproduction was only confirmed in the north-eastern part of the distribution range. If the present situation continues for only for a few more years, the Asiatic cheetah will be lost forever.

Once widespread in Central, South and South-west Asia, Acinonyx jubatus venaticus was first assessed in the IUCN Red List in 1986 as Endangered. Ten years later, it was up-listed to Critically Endangered CR and has remained so ever since. The data base was never really satisfying, but the CR listing was and is certainly justified.

In January 1998, Peter Jackson, then chairman of the IUCN SSC Cat Specialist Group, visited Iran to discuss cheetah conservation. In 2001, the Department of Environment DoE and the Unite Nations Development Program UNDP launched the Conservation of the Asiatic Cheetah Project CACP, a medium size GEF project running until 2008. In 2010, the Cat Specialist Group hosted a workshop in Switzerland for the development of an Action Plan for the second phase of the CACP. This plan was a joint effort of the DoE, CACP, UNDP, the Cat SG, the Wildlife Conservation Society WCS, Panthera, and the Cheetah Conservation Fund CCF.

In 2010, we were quite optimistic. Awareness for cheetah conservation in Iran was high, and the capacity for law enforcement, monitoring and implementation of conservation measures had considerably improved thanks to CACP phase I. However, funding for the implementation of CACP phase II was short from the beginning. UNDP provided track funds for the CACP office, but national and international financial support needed for the implementation of the Action Plan was difficult to find. The sanctions against Iran impeded international support, and budget cuts in the DoE made it increasingly difficult to even continue routine patrolling and law enforcement activities in the cheetah areas. NGOs such as ICS and the Persian Wildlife Heritage Foundation PWHF continued their field projects, and WCS provided regular expert support, but protection, conservation activities and monitoring were generally low in the past ten years.

In June 2017, I visited Tehran and met with people from the DoE, conservation NGOs and wildlife scientists to discuss the status of the cheetah, the achievements of CACP II and the possible way forward. The review was sobering. But there is still hope. In the north-east of the distribution range, cheetahs have responded positively on an increase in gazelle numbers. In Touran National Park and Miandasht Protected Area, females with cubs have been observed. But then, these marvellous cats get killed on a dangerous road separating the two protected areas. Nevertheless, the experience demonstrates that mitigating the threats and improving habitat and prey would allow stabilising and increasing the local cheetah abundance.

What we now need is an emergency rescue plan for the Asiatic cheetah, a global campaign similar to what helped saving the Iberian lynx from extinction some 15 years ago!

A modest start has been made: 31 August 2017 was “Cheetah Day” in Iran, and the plight of the Yuzpalang and the public support from a famous actress has allowed piling up crowd funding that should help buying out grazing rights of local communities in the core area of Touran NP to reduce conflict with shepherd dogs. But more will be needed, much more of about everything: Commitment, awareness, and above all funding, to be invested in cheetah protection, prey enhancement, habitat amelioration, road mitigation, local people involvement, reliable monitoring, and targeted research. The DoE and the conservation NGOs involved will not be able to successfully run an Asiatic cheetah rescue programme on their own. The support of the international conservation community is needed, and Iran will also need international funding to run such a project. To me, such support seems self-evident. The Asiatic cheetah was once a symbol of the south-west Asian steppe and semi-deserts, roaming across many countries. Now it is restricted to one region in one country, but it is the liability of the global conservation community to prevent the terminal extinction of this formidable felid.

With this issue of Cat News, we are taking up the call again, with three articles on the Asiatic cheetah (pages 4 to 13). Saving the Asiatic cheetah is one of the top priorities in cat conservation in the years to come.

Urs Breitenmoser

Letter to the editors: Time to get real about the Asiatic cheetah conservation by M. Eslami, N. Gholikhani and E. M. Moqanaki

The global distribution of the Asiatic cheetah Acinonyx jubatus venaticus, with as few as 50 individuals left in the wild, is now restricted to two habitat patches of over 140,000 km² in Iran’s central plateau. Already Critically Endangered, in 2001 an international initiative entitled Conservation of the Asiatic Cheetah, Its Natural Habbitat, and Associated Biota in the I. R. of Iran CACP was put together to halt the imminent cheetah extinction. Efforts associatedwith CACP have successfully

  1. Promoted establishment of new protected areas across the cheetah range (known as cheetah reserves CRs);
  2. Strengthened law enforcement in CRs;
  3. Recovered CRs’ ungulate prey populations;
  4. Raised awareness of the pubblic and stakeholders abbout the cheetah conservation; and
  5. developed research and conservation capacity.

However, conservationists are now divided on whether these achievements have been sufficient to reverse the Asiatic cheetah’s extinction trajectory.

With the cooperation of CACP, the Iranian Department of Environment DoE and several local partners, the Iranian Cheetah Society ICS set up a large-scale monitoring effort across multiple CRs in 2011 to update the conservation status of the Asiatic cheetah population. Through five years of intensive camera-trapping surveys with the total effort of over 28,500 trap-nights at 467 stations in 11 sites across 13,000 km² core of the cheetah range, only 17 adult cheetahs (10 males, 5 females and 2 of unknown sex) were identified. Disturbingly, no verifiable evidence of female cheetahs was obtained across two-third of the subspecies’ presumed range. No new cheetah individuals were recorded since 2012. In addition, human-related deaths of two photo-captured cheetahs (one male and one female) are already confirmed (Fig. 1). ICS’ surveys strongly suggest that viabble cheetah subpopulations with reproducing females are now limited to the northern habitat patch.

The Asiatic cheetah conservation is entangled with the subspecies’ extremely low population size, but more importantly that this population is fractured into smaller subpopulations across two landscapes with little to no connectivity. ICS findings show that cheetahs of different sex and age groups disperse widely across multiple CRs in an unpredictable movement pattern. On the one hand, this nomadic lifestyle can be imperative for persistence of the Iranian cheetah population by reversing local extinctions. On the other hand, the complex life history and social behaviour of Asiatic cheetahs in combination with the weak enforcement capacity outside the current CRs make their effective conservation extremely difficult. Additionally, the apparent male-skewed sex ratio of cheetah subpopulations turns them into declining sink populations. The inadequate political will to mitigate continuing external threats to the Asiatic cheetah survival has been partly responsible for the failure of current conservation activities:

  1. Traditional pastoralism within CRs continues to bring tens of thousands of livestock, guarding dogs and herders to the core of cheetah habitat and has resulted in direct killing of at least 21 cheetahs since 2001. This herding practice also poses indirect threats to cheetahs by disturbing the habitat and through competition with the wild prey over food and water sources.
  2. Hotspots of cheetah-vehicle collisions are not mitigated and the habitat fragmentation is continuing and increasing. Road mortalities of cheetahs include at least 15 individuals of both sexes since 2001.
  3. Unsustainable mining development and its associated secondary impacts, such as habitat alteration, infrastructure expansion, human migration and illegal hunting, remains one of the biggest threats to the cheetah habitat, and new exploration plans are even threatening CRs as the decline in cheetah numbers weakens DoE’s position in relation to extractive ministries and industries.

CACP has been a collaborative effort of numerous national and international partner organisations and conservationists during the past 16 years. The extinction of the Asiatic cheetah would a conservation failure not only for Iran, but also for the entire initiative. All partners must admit the urgency of the situation, and play an active role in the decision-making process to safeguard the future of Asiatic cheetahs. What Asiatic cheetah conservation urgently requires is negotiations at high levels to encourage the Iranian government to take a clear responsibility about the fate of the Asiatic cheetah. If the Iranian government really wants to save cheetahs, it must be ready for huge investments and large-scale conservation interventions. Simultaneously, the current initiative needs to prioritise pragmatic solutions, and seriously consider manipulative management actions for subpopulations with no evidence of female cheetah presence. Delaying immediate measures for the sake of gaining more data on the cheetah status will only lead to monitoring cheetahs to extinction. Without a country-scale rigorous conservation effort that puts its goal to solely, and urgently, preservethe cheetah population and its habitat, the Asiatic cheetah will soon be a conservation failure story.

An evaluation of the achievements of the Conservation of Asiatic Cheetah Project in Iran by S. Ostrowski

The Conservation of the Asiatic Cheetah Project CACP in Iran has reached by 2016 some degree of achievements for 63% of the activities proposed in the 2010-2014 Action Plan.  The objectives related to capacity building, protection and law enforcement could be considered reached, whereas those linked to policy, economics, monitoring and land use planning were in general less achieved. CACP operation suffered from low and unstable funding, frequently changing leadership at the Department of Environment DoE level, weakly responsive administrations, a lack of collaboration between national partners and a rather complex and sometimes confusing Action Plan. Despite a reasonably high level of achievement of activities proposed by the 2010-2014 Action Plan, the Asiatic cheetah Acinonyx jubatus venaticus remains Critically Endangered. A review of threats and actions should be considered for the next Action Plan.

 

Supporting Online Material

Figures F1 & F2 and Tables T1-T3

The current status of Asiatic cheetah in Iran by L. Khalatbari, H. Jowkar, G. H. Yusefi, J. C. Brito and S. Ostrowski

The current distribution of Asiatic cheetah Acinonyx jubatus venaticus in Iran is fragmented in three scattered subpopulations in the central arid plateau. Population size is unknown but tentatively estimated at less than 50 individuals. We review the historic and current status, population trend, and threats to cheetah survival in Iran, and present conservation actions recommended by Iranian experts. Between 2015 and 2017, 26 different individuals have been recorded in protected areas based on camera trapping and direct observation. The northern subpopulation in Touran Biosphere Reserve BR and Miandasht Wildlife Refuge WR is the only one with evidence of reproduction. No reproduction has been observed in the southern subpopulation since 2012, suggesting that it is decreasing in size and range. No cheetah presence has been recorded in the western subpopulation since 2013. Despite the conservation efforts of the last 15 years the cheetah in Iran remains Critically Endangered. Urgent conservation interventions are needed to protect the last remaining individuals. The combined engagement and contribution of national and international partners will be critical for the success of these interventions.

 

Supporting Online Material

Figures F1 & F2 and Table T1

National Strategy and Action Plan for Arabian leopard in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia by M. Zafar-ul Islam, A. Boug and A. Al-Shehri

Records suggest that Arabian leopard Panthera pardus nimr distribution may has declined by over 90% since the beginning of the 19th century, with the population reaching its presently highly precarious status at the start of the 21st century. A National Strategy and Action Plan developed by Prince Saud al-Faisal Wildlife Research Centre PSFWRS based on the Regional Strategy and Action Plan together with the Saudi Vision 2030. The overall objective of the plan is “to prevent the extinction of Arabian leopards in Saudi Arabia and the loss of the Saudi Arabian leopard gene pool”. The key actions and targets are (1) update comprehensive distribution maps for leopards in Saudi Arabia; (2) Determine the status of wild populations, and identify current trends and threats; (3) Identify critical sites within which the full protection of wild leopards is feasible and support the Saudi Wildlife Authority SWA initiatives to gain formal recognition for such sites; (4) Enhance the captive population; (5) Coordinate the leopard conservation programme within Gulf Cooperation Council and (6) Commence environmental education & awareness.

 

Supporting Online Material

Figures F1 & F2 and Table T1

First camera trap record of caracal kittens in Oman by H. Al Hikmani, K. M. A. Al Hikmani

Despite its wide distribution, little is known about the breeding period or litter size of the caracal Caracal caracal schmitzi in Oman. We present here the first camera trap photograph of twin kittens in the wild.

First sand cat kittens sighted in the MOroccan Sahara by A. Sliwa, S. Azizi, E. Alifal, A. Essalhi, M. Endichi and G. Breton

We report here on the first sighting and photographic documentation of kittens of African sand cats Felis margarita margarita in the region of Addrar Souttouf in the Moroccan Sahara near the Atlantic coast in late April 2017.

 

Supporting Online Material

Figure F1 and link Video V1

Video V1

Jungle cats are threatened by free-ranging urban dogs by H. Basnet, S. Gurung, A. Kunwar and B. Katuwal

Based on opportunistic sightings, we studied the conflicts between the jungle cat Felis chaus and free-ranging urban dogs at Pulchowk Engineering College, Lalitpur, Nepal in 2014-2015. In the space of two years two jungle cats were killed, two managed to escape, while the status of another one was unknown. We believe that such killing and chasing may cause serious threats to the survival of the jungle cat. Proper and timely management of free-ranging urban dogs is necessary to save the jungle cat in an urban environment.

 

Supporting Online Material

Figures F1 & F2 and Table T1

High elevation record of the leopard cat in Bhagajang wetland complex, India by R. Chakraborty, L. T. Nahmo, J. Upadhyay and K. Medhi

Leopard cat Prionailurus bengalensis, one of the most widespread and adaptable small felid in Asia, is generally living in a variety of habitats, except high alpine areaswith deep snow cover. We camera trapped a leopard cat in remote highlands of Bhagajang Wetland Complex, Tawang district, Arunachal Pradesh, India, at 4,250 m, in a rhododendron-juniper alpine scrub habitat. This record represents the highest documented presence record of the species in India and shows the versatility of the leopard cat in surviving in harsh habitats.

First picture of snow leopard in Kumaon Himalayas, Bageshwar, Uttarakhand, India by V. Maurya, S. B. Lal and P. M. Dhakate

The snow leopard Panthera uncia is probably the most charismatic carnivore to roam the mountains of Asia. The aim of our study was to collect more information about snow leopard presence, prey availability in the area and other carnivores and wildlife in the Kumaon region of Himalayas, the west-central section of the Himalayas in northern India. Our study was conducted from November 2013 to January 2014. Snow leopard occurrence in the region was confirmed and we report here the first photographic evidence of snow leopard in Bageshwar district, State of Uttarakhand.

First estimates of fishing cat abundance and density in Lothian WS, Sundarbans, India by S. K. Das, R. Saha, S. Mukherjee, A. A. Danda and J. Borah

Estimates of population density are helpful to prioritise investments and assess the effectiveness of conservation interventions for wildlife and their habitat. This paper outlines the first application of systematic camera trapping to estimate density and abundance of fishing cat Prionailurus viverrinus in the Lothian Wildlife Sanctuary WS in the Indian Sundarbans. A total of 13 individual fishing cats were identified based on their pelage patterns. Using mark-recapture statistical models, we estimated a population size of 14 ± 2.5 individuals and a density of 0.44 ± 0.13 individuals per km². The activity pattern of fishing cats was mainly crepuscular. The study has established a baseline for the long-term monitoring of fishing cats in the Sundarbans. It is a poorly known threatened felid species and future research is recommended to understand its status, resource use, reproductive biology and home range in a mangrove ecosystem as well as in other forested areas.

 

Supporting Online Material

Figure F1 and Table T1

Living with the leopard in Gorkha District, Nepal by M. B. Gurung and S. Dahal

Leopard Panthera pardus is the most widely distributed large felid which profoundly uses human dominated landscapes. A leopard was observed by local people on 18 May 2014 in Boksepani of Gorkha bazaar, Nepal. The news was broadcasted by local FM radios, initiating a field survey of leopards to understand the potential hazards to humans and possible human-leopard conflicts. Field observations were made from 18 June to 29 November 2014 in the middle of the human settlement in Boksepani, Gorkha. Direct observations and formal and informal interviews with the local community revealed that the leopard used the area frequently as a den. The leopard was observed six times and its behaviour was recorded. During the study period, the leopard was once recorded entering the human settlement. There were records of the leopard raiding poultry, pig and stray dogs but the direct impact on humans could not be determined. Albeit the leopard was not seen again in June 2017 and may has already left the area, it possibly will return in the future and potentially cause human-leopard conflicts.

 

Supporting Online Material

Tables T1 & T2 and Figure F1

Does the marbled cat exist in Nepal? by B. V. Dahal and S. Dahal

The marbled cat Pardofelis marmorata is an elusive small cat on which few specific studies were conducted. This article reviews the literature on distribution records of marbled cat to assess the likelihood of its current existence in Nepal. Beside a single record from the early 1980s, there are no recent records to prove the existence of the marbled cat in Nepal. However, the Government of Nepal and the distribution map of the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species assume that the marbled cat is extant in Nepal. To support the Government’s official statement on marbled cat presence in the country and to validate the IUCN distribution map for Nepal, a marbled cat targeted camera trap survey in potential habitats is urgently needed.

 

Supporting Online Material 

Table T1

Marking behaviours of jaguars in a tropical rainforest of southern Mexico by V. Towns, R. León, J. de la Maza and J. A. de la Torre

Large solitary felids have to communicate indirectly with their conspecifics to advertise their presence and social status, to find mates and to maintain their land tenure system. However, there is little information about the social behaviour of jaguars Panthera onca. We investigated the marking behaviour of several jaguars on a trail located within the Montes Azules Biosphere Reserve BR, southern Mexico. We evaluated the different marking behaviours of jaguars and the jaguar preferences to mark certain trees. We found that jaguars preferred the highest trees and those with a wider diameter at breast height for claw marking. Recorded marking behaviours included: claw marking a tree, spraying urine and rubbing the tree. One male jaguar visited the marking tree at three different occasions accompanied by two different females. The most interesting aspect of our findings is that at least seven individuals (four males and three females) used the exact same tree as an important communication spot.

 

Supporting Online Material

Tables T1-T3

Video V1 copyright Natura & Ecosistemas Mexicanos A.C

Video V2 copyright Natura & Ecosistemas Mexicanos A.C

New records of jaguar predation on sea turtles, Pacific coast, Costa Rica by L. G. Fonseca, S. Arroyo-Arce, I. Thomson, W. N. Villachica and R. A. Valverde

We report here new sites where jaguars Panthera onca prey upon sea turtles in Costa Rica. We conducted carcass counts (n = 228) along eight beaches located in Santa Rosa National Park NP, which makes part of Guanacaste Conservation Area, between June and August 2016. The olive ridley sea turtle Lepidochelys olivacea was the most common species predated by jaguars (50% carcasses), followed by the green sea turtle Chelonia mydas (30%) and the hawksbill sea turtle Eretmochelys imbricata (0.44%). The site with the most predation events (41%) was Nancite beach. Our results suggest that predation levels could be influenced by both prey availability (e.g. sea turtles) and jaguar distribution on each beach. This information will not only improve our knowledge regarding the distribution of jaguar predation across the country, but also increase our understanding about this predator-prey interaction.

 

Supporting Online Material

Table T1

Social behaviour of pumas in Torres del Paine Naitonal Park, Chile by N. Lagos, C. Sepúlveda, R. Pino, B. Segura, J. Gerstle, F. Gamboa and C. Muñoz-Donoso

Largely studied across the American continent, the puma Puma concolor has been considered a solitary-living species. However, 118 interactions between adult pumashave been documented in Grand Teton National Park NP, USA, providing evidenceof unusual social behaviour for this species. In 2016, while filming pumas in Torres del Paine National Park TPNP in Chile, our team documented a total of 11 social interactions between adult and subadult pumas, confirming that the species is not as solitary as thought.